Showing posts with label Amazon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Amazon. Show all posts

Thursday, 9 July 2015

App-only Strategy? Some Should Think Again

So another ecommerce player is going the app-only way. Flipkart has now decided that it will go the Myntra way, and become app-only by September this year. I had written earlier about Myntra's move in a blog post and why it makes sense for this company to be app-only. You can read the same here. Well, although Myntra reported a 10% dip in its revenue after the D-date, I am still convinced that this strategy will work for the company. One of the sole reasons for this is that Myntra is essentially a vertical ecommerce player. If someone has to buy a dress or an accessory, Myntra has got tremendous collection at good prices to lure the customer in. And frankly, there are no other players who are as good as Myntra when it comes to fashion and accessory shopping.

There have been many reasons cited by many experts when Myntra had first announced about the change in strategy, like low penetration of internet, slow internet speed in the country, trust issues during mobile payments etc. These have been revived again with the announcement from Flipkart. Though I am not refuting any of the above points, but I believe these issues are not going to be there forever and things will evolve. They always do. What I am concerned are 2 aspects which one should consider when thinking about an app-only strategy, especially a horizontal player.

1. There is a big difference between vertical and horizontal ecommerce players and a one-size-fits-all strategy may not work at all. Especially in a market like India. These marketplaces, namely Flipkart, Amazon, Snapdeal and PayTm, house nearly everything you have ever thought of buying. There was a time around 1-2 years back when a new wave was sweeping Indian ecommerce industry with manufacturers going for exclusive tie-ups with ecommerce companies. Flipkart had pioneered it with its announcements with Motorola and Xiaomi. Soon other players rushed doing the same, with Micromax and OnePlus choosing one ecommerce player over the other. However, this trend has slowly lost steam and companies like Xiaomi and OnePlus have put their wares in a competing warehouse as well now. One sole reason for this is to reach as many customers as possible. The fallout of this is that even the little bit of exclusivity which was available to these players is slowly fading away. Every product is available at every other site. A potential customer will buy a product from a site he is most comfortable with at that point of time. He is certainly not going to waste his time and data on downloading an app, when at the same time he can use that data in viewing another ecommerce player site and, possibly, completing the whole transaction. He is not concerned too much on the discounts (which are reducing these days anyway), but more concerned about the choices he can get at the time he wants them. Not having a mobile site and a desktop site seriously hampers a player's ability to capture that customer. It can work in a vertical player's business, like Myntra's, but an app-only strategy stands on a very weak footing for a horizontal player.

2. Despite some of the problems and challenges listed above (like internet penetration etc), the biggest challenge for Indian players can come from the ubiquitous Google. Google has already announced its intentions of bringing a 'buy' button in its search results. This same feature is already available for flight bookings in India (read my previous post on this here). Imagine searching for a product on Google, and the search results show the product along with prices and buy button from 3 players (competitors) and your site is not listed, just because you don't have a site anymore and only have an app. Let's think that even though Flipkart doesn't have a site, Google still gives the search results including listing from Flipkart along with Snapdeal and others. Still, if a customer clicks on the Flipkart link, it will prompt for either opening the app or downloading the same. That too, if the customer is on a tablet or phone while browsing. If, by chance, he is on a laptop (and there is considerable possibility for this), even the app-download option won't be there. And all the talks about 'seamless buying experience' and 'comfortable user experience' stand for nothing more than mere words. The "problem" of Google won't be gone, whatever happens in the ecommerce space. The best way for the players to tackle this is to turn this apparent problem to an asset. And that is possible when you keep open all the avenues (app, mobile site, desktop site, smartwatch option).

As I said earlier, an app-only strategy still makes sense but not for all the players. A Myntra, UrbanLadder, PepperTap, BlueStone can afford to think about the above strategy and potentially be available only as an app, but horizontal players can hardly afford this luxury anymore. It may lead to customer stickiness for a small section of buyers, a big section may totally avoid the troubles of downloading an app and instead do a Google search instead.

Please comment your thoughts below. Tweet to me at @NishantSinha88.

Thursday, 18 June 2015

A Game of Thrones..of a Different Kind!

So Game of Thrones completed the airing of its 5th season last Sunday, and speculations and spoilers have been on full swing regarding Jon Snow and other characters. By the way, nothing to worry for you folks, there are no spoilers here. Sometimes, I guess even the creator of the series, Mr George R R Martin (affectionately or due to a long name, also referred to as GRRM) would wonder at all the plot twists the TV show has, and the deviations from what is there in the books. Halting this digression of our own about the GoT show, let us turn our thoughts to another little game which has become equally exciting over the last few years, with no clear leader in sight (leave alone thinking about winning). This is the game of e-commerce in India.

The e-commerce space in India has been touted as one of the major frontiers to conquer for many companies. All the major empires are leaving no stone unturned to bleed themselves dry in order to catch hold of a bigger pie of Westeros (the consumers’ wallet). The bloodbath in the name of discounts and offers have been coming from all the players over the last few years, and although the discounts have mellowed down a bit, there doesn’t seem a clear change of strategy in order to capture the throne. Same as in the GoT series, there are 4 major players in the Indian e-commerce domain, viz. Flipkart, Amazon, PayTm and Snapdeal. Although Flipkart leads the market-share currently (Lannisters?), none of the other players are too much behind. We also have niche players, just like the smaller empires in the series, which occasionally get acquired by a bigger player and in turn, add to the arsenal of the larger empire. The 2 biggest of such M&As have been that of Myntra (by Flipkart) and FreeCharge (by Snapdeal). Did anyone mention about Tyrells’ and Boltons’ closeness (or the lack of it) with Baratheons, Starks and Lannisters? And how can we forget the dragons in this game as well. Any guesses?

I was surprised at the parallels we can draw between the two completely different subjects. I am sure a more creative mind can find many more connections between e-commerce and the hugely popular series, but let us also focus on what strategy can the different empires undertake to win this game in India. And we need to look no further than the creator of the series, GRRM. Let’s look at it in some detail, shall we?

  • G - Grocery: Ecommerce in groceries is not as easy as it sounds. Period. To state the obvious, this segment has not been really cracked by the 4 biggies. We do have a few successful models in front of us which have started on really well and are gaining some good traction in their home markets. Grofers and PepperTap have been working on 2 completely different models among themselves, the former ties up with local kirana stores and hence does not necessarily own any inventory, whereas the latter has been mostly working on an inventory-led model. There are other niche players as well like LocalBanya, BigBasket and AaramShop, among others. Amazon India recently launched its Kirana Now program in Bangalore and has been piloting different models to see what systems will actually work in India. A year or so earlier, Sachin Bansal had been quoted by some sources that Flipkart will not be entering into groceries and F&B ecommerce, however, it’s a known for a fact that even the market leader won’t be able to hold onto its position for far too long if it does not crack the groceries business. PayTm has been piloting grocery retailing in Bangalore for around a month and a half now, and this business will most likely be as a separate vertical for the Alibaba-backed company. Snapdeal already has a tie-up with Godrej’s Nature Fresh for retailing groceries and it is expected to extend the presence and deliveries to other cities very soon. It is very apparent that everyone wants to crack the code of this segment, which has been touted to grow at 25-30% per annum in the major cities of the country. The biggest challenge in groceries will be the perishability factor, and control over deliveries while keeping the costs down. As we have seen Game of Thrones, help can come from any quarter if you are in trouble. The same may well happen here as well. Did anyone mention Ola and Uber?

  • R - Rural: Tier 2, 3 cities along with other parts of rural India has been witnessing phenomenal growth in smartphone usage, helped in a major part by improvement in internet penetration. Flipkart, Amazon and most of the Indian ecommerce companies have gone on record stating a major chunk of their sales happening in non-metro cities. Nearly all of them have separate teams working dedicatedly to connect India’s deep hinterlands with the commerce happening from the comfort of a shopper’s home. Amazon has warehouses on the outskirts of Bangalore, which cater to demands from towns like Belgaum and Hosur. They have employed local village entrepreneurs and assigned the task of deliveries in these towns, thereby greatly reducing the last-mile logistics costs. Snapdeal too has set up village kiosks where the company keeps its wares and locals are encouraged to order through smartphones or village desktops. The company uses this kiosks as pickup points as well, where villagers can come and receive their ordered goods, thus eliminating the last-mile connectivity in these cases. However, as much as the potential which these smaller cities and towns hold, they are still part of an unconquered frontier owing to lack of quality infrastructure and logistics in India. To succeed in rural India, companies will have to focus on simple, yet innovative, ideas. One such idea has been piloted by Amazon earlier (and now launched at full scale) is that of a tie-up with India Post. Amazon has a similar tie-up with US Post in US and has brought down the same idea to India. Flipkart and Snapdeal also have recently moved together with India Post and have begun to take advantages of nearly 500,000 post offices across the country for deliveries. The biggest beneficiary of this has been India Post itself, as this gives a chance to it to bring back its days of glory. Having strong networks and partnerships always helps, as Lord Baelish will gladly tell us. 

  • R - Returns: Returns and reverse logistics have always been areas of concerns for ecommerce companies and sellers, although they provide immense value to the end-customer, who can literally pick and choose the products s/he wants. Returns add a lot of cost to companies and it affects more severely the sellers, as most of the ecommerce companies are running on the marketplace model. Some companies have tried solving this problem in unique ways and there is a lot to learn from them. Apparel and accessories company YeBhi.com gives a choice of 5 dresses which a customer can order during purchases. The delivery person will bring the 5 dresses, which can be tried out by the customer. In the end, the customer can keep the one which is the best fit and the delivery guy returns with the other 4 dresses. This method reduces one complete trip for the delivery personnel, and at the same time, adds a bit of personalization as well. The same model, with some variations, is being followed by Lenskart.com as well, where in it brings some set of eye-wears to the customer’s doorsteps and the latter can pick and choose the one which gives the desired look. India’s largest mobile commerce company, Snapdeal, too has been working diligently on this front. It has already acquired a stake in the logistics company GoJavas and together they have launched a 90-minute return policy in 15 cities of India. That’s how e-commerce is changing how customers shop now, with same-day deliveries and 90-minute returns. Other players soon will catch-up and we might see reductions in pick-up times from 90 to 30 minutes.

  • M - Mobile: We spend a lot of time on our mobiles. We might actually be looking at photos and people more on our screens, than lifting our heads and seeing actual people. Some of us might be watching the entire GoT series on mobile. E-commerce cannot be behind then, can it? Companies have already started shutting down their websites and going app-only. A lot of companies have been app-only since their inception and have little intention of marking their presence on a desktop as well. Mobile commerce is here to stay and companies like Myntra and PayTm may well be on the path to actually define how the game will be played in the near future. With PayTm applying for a banking license as well, mobile payments and virtual cards might actually make a few ATMs shut their shops. Even Lord Varys would have to agree that technology has been moving at a pace faster than birds’ whispers.



E-commerce has been in India for quite some time now (with sites like IndiaMart etc), however the real seeds were sown when Flipkart started up in 2007 and has been the leader sitting happily in King’s Landing since. The competition has caught up with it now, with 3 other major players vying for the coveted throne of "India’s biggest e-commerce player". From US to China (remember the Alibaba ‘Dragons’ we talked about earlier?), everyone is trying to gain a share of our (mobile) wallets.

A lot of bloodbath has happened through discounts and although things are a bit calm now, I believe the Indian pie is big enough to accommodate these 4 players (and more) along with the smaller niche ones. We certainly don’t want a 'Valar Morghulis' situation here, with each one killing the other off, do we? The key to supremacy may well lie in #GRRM (just like the TV series and the books). #GoT it?


Please feel free to comment with your thoughts. Tweet to me @NishantSinha88.

Thursday, 4 June 2015

New Frontiers for Ecommerce

Ecommerce has taken the world by storm. Its not-so-new 'sister concern', m-commerce is turning a new page in online buying, with Myntra, India's largest online fashion and apparel company, going app-only last month. However, we might be on the verge of seeing new platforms, which most of us didn't think of going the ecommerce way, changing the way we shop online. Some prominent among these, in the very near future, will be Google, Twitter and Pinterest.

1. Google: Google recently initiated talks of featuring a 'buy' button in its search results, thus enabling a customer to buy from the search page directly. Google's most important service to the world has been its ability to organize the world's knowledge and the company makes big bucks through advertisements on its search page and AdWords. But, this side of the business could very well be witnessing its biggest competition so far, shopping apps.

Nearly, every company has moved over to promoting its app for buying anything and everything available on its portal. Taking example of India, its ecommerce market is slated to touch US$ 300b by 2030, according to a recent report by a global bank. If consumers go to native apps of ecommerce players for searching and shopping, it could become a huge opportunity lost for Google if consumers bypass its services. All the AdWords and other features won't do much good to Google if people don't really go to its site for their shopping needs. And this is why, Google is planning to incorporate the Buy feature in its search results. They already have put some aspects of this feature while searching for flights in India (on google.co.in). Currently, if you search for a flight on Google India, it will give you details of the prices and timings and button for booking the flight. Clicking on the button takes you to the site of the airline, with another option to look for other prices on Goibibo (only aggregator listed as of now). So, although payments and other options have not been provided currently by Google, but they sure are going to focus on this now. With mobile wallets slowly picking up (courtesy PayTm, MobiKwik, Airtel Money etc), Google Wallets won't have to work too hard for customer acquisition, when you can use the wallet for any purchase across categories. Ecommerce players like Flipkart, Amazon will be wise to see this happening sooner rather than later. They can buy slots on Google search pages for their products, with consumers getting all different options to buy a product of his choice without having to download a lot of apps. Also, the recent Google I/O conference talked about how the company is planning to use its biggest weapon in its arsenal, Android, by allowing the OS to read the user data from all the apps installed on a phone and tailoring the search accordingly. Google is increasing the bar and defending its territory, for sure.

2. Twitter: Any company which is focused on serving its customers has taken the twitter route. This platform has helped them be in touch with their customers to solve their concerns, launch new products, launch new campaigns and do just about anything. How about enabling the companies to sell on Twitter as well? Twitter did come up with a plan to introduce a Buy button in US last year, it hasn't seen much traction there, or any other markets globally. Imagine buying stuffs directly from tweets, with just a few clicks. An artist just launched a new song and the music company has tweeted about it. Along with the RT and Favorite buttons, there is a Buy button as well alongside the tweet, from where you can legally buy the new song without the need of an iTunes or other such service. Or think about buying the newly launched book for your Kindle, without leaving the Twitter interface. Extend the idea to any product you see these days. This service will be a pure-play marketplace as Twitter is not going to hold inventories and sellers can sell any item they wish. Combine this with customized offers through the 'big data' which gets generated on Twitter, brands and companies can target their customers with pinpoint accuracy. Some months back, ICICI Bank, India's largest private sector bank, introduced transfer of funds through the use of tweets and DMs. With Indian ecommerce growing at the pace as it is currently, a lot can be done in products and services through Twitter. As such, the potential of Twitter is immense for a market like India, which has one of the fastest growing user base who tweet day in and day out.


3. Pinterest: User-generated and curated content has been garnering quite a lot of talk lately, with some startups in the 'Silicon Valleys' of US and India already grabbing VCs' attention and (more importantly) money. Although this is still at a nascent stage for India, Pinterest is not for brands. A lot of brands have very active accounts on this website (a prominent example being Myntra). Pinterest, however, is monetizing now. It has begun testing and piloting 'Buyable Pins' in US, where customers can buy an item while just browsing pics. The logistics is handled by the sellers themselves and (currently) payments are handled through PayPal and other leading services in the US. Pinterest is still to gain a lot of traction in India, but going by the trend of other platforms, a focused approach towards India can make it one of the fastest growing and leading markets for any platform (prominent examples being LinkedIn, Whatsapp, Facebook, Twitter and more recently, Amazon). Pinterest through its Buy buttons (or pins) in the Indian market can aim for the disruption that it might be seeking. Indians, most often, don't really shop when they have to. For apparels, people keep browsing (window-shopping, a few years back) and buy a dress when something suits the eye. This nicely mimics how people interact on Pinterest as well (apart from the buying part). They browse through images and post or pin the ones they like. Pinterest can ideally up the game a little bit by adding that 'buy' button next to the 'pin' button.

In one of my earlier posts (read here), I had talked about how the app-only strategy is here to stay and why Myntra's latest move deserves appreciation. I still believe most of the other players will try going this route sooner rather than later, as it can result in customer stickiness. However, the 3 platforms explained above, can be the shot in the arm that the (current) offline players need. A Bharti Retail or a Future Group might get more interested in selling through Google or Twitter than an Amazon or a Myntra. This will give them a lot of traction right at the beginning of their game, and not worry a lot about customer acquisition and discounts.

The ecommerce game has only begun for India and other countries, and a lot of new chapters are yet to conceptualized and written. Sit back and witness the changes and uncertainties. One thing which is certain, however, is that the end-customer will be the final winner.

Comment your thoughts below or on twitter @NishantSinha88.

Saturday, 16 May 2015

App-only Strategy: Here to Stay

A lot of chatter happened this week on apps and ecommerce. Myntra, which had decided to go app-only, executed its plan and on 15 May shutdown its website. Some of other major ecommerce players were asked what did they think of this move and if they too will take a similar road. The answer was a resounding NO from the likes of Snapdeal, Jabong and Amazon India.

So what exactly is going on here, with one player betting everything on an app-only approach, whereas others summarily rejecting this move in the near future? For starters, its a very bold move by Myntra in an industry which is still in its infancy and none of the players are yet to show sustainability in cash flow and profits. There are 2 major aspects why this move can be called a bold one. Every company has been going all guns blazing for the past couple of years for acquiring new customers and thereby increasing sales. No one wants to leave any stone unturned in customer acquisition, be it through websites, apps, social media interaction. You name it. Given this relentless push for customers, some have argued as to why force the customer to go to the app, and why not get them coming through website as well.

The 2nd reason is Myntra's product groups i.e. apparels. Shoppers do get a better experience on a larger screen of a laptop when buying clothes and other apparels. An image on a 5-inch or so smartphone will not give a laptop-type experience to shoppers especially while buying the above kind of items.

Let's analyze the above from an objective eye. The largest customer chunk for any established player in India is coming through its app, and not its website or mobile-site. Each of these companies has been doling out special offers on app since the beginning of last year and before. So, its safe to assume that every company wants its sales to go through its respective app. If that's the case, a hue and cry over closure of Myntra's website is on a very weak footing. If every company is betting high on apps-based shopping, there is no place for halfhearted efforts. One has to see the larger picture and go all-in and that's why, Myntra's move is not just a small change in strategy, its a move towards the future. More so, its a move towards creating the future, just as what its parent Flipkart did when it pioneered ecommerce in India in 2007. And we already have examples of services which are app-based solely, rather than having a website (eg, Uber, although one can argue its a completely different model and industry).

The 2nd point as has been mentioned above about small-screen shopping of apparels can also be looked more objectively. We all agree that ecommerce is here to stay. However when it had all started a few years ago, people used to argue that shoppers need to have a 'touch and feel' experience before buying and ecommerce seriously lacks in this. Fast-forward to today, and there is hardly anything which people are not buying through ecommerce. Similar analogy can be drawn for the above argument as well. Small screen or not, mobile and wearables are the future and merely talking about it won't cut the ice. We need companies like Myntra who believe in walking the talk. And those who still want to stick to argument of no-small-screen, they should take a look at Apple Watch and some other companies who are already developing apps for smart-watches.

Skeptics will always be there, but as I said Myntra's move is bold and a very smart one towards building a new future. And I haven't said a word about leveraging customer data and personalizing the experience. There will be hiccups along the way for sure. Myntra will probably need to provide an app-experience which is more than just 'browsing-selecting-paying'. But kudos to Myntra and I believe this move is a potential game changer and I won't be surprised if other players too join the bandwagon.

Please feel free to pitch in with your comments.